I Swiped the Wrong One 2026

Ethan Lyvers Tyler Angela Katherine Baker Stephanie Laura Irene Young Jessica Joe Fishel Congressman Brian Ceponis Chief of Staff Richard Patterson Jessica Buck Brittanny Michael Z. Atrata Dating Service Owner Benjamin Sheeler Landscaper Angel R. Reed Congressman's Wife Jeff Monahan Funeral Speaker Christopher Kai Ashley's Martial Arts Date Reed Mack Ashley’s Older Date Alex Blair Ashley’s Disco Date Ryan Beatrice Ashley's Bigfoot Date Nelia Rose Holley Theater Director Dawn Renee Robby Neal's Mother John W. Iwanonkiw Robby Neal's Father Frank Perman Stand-Up Comedian Brett Sullivan Santry Lord Macbeth Actor Alyssa Herron Lady Macbeth Actress Gregory Johnstone Theater Patron Kristine Beckett Barista #1 Cheryl L. Sorice Barista #2 Hannah Mros Barista #3 Morgan Zajac Barista #4 Dennis McCann Theater Shusher Rebecca Henry Theater Actor Jennifer Rizzi Horvath Bike Shop Cafe Staff Nathan Kirby Pool Player #1 Jacorey Guidry Pool Player #2 Olga Polik Reporter Nicholas Lombardo Man in Coffee Shop Dauby Baublitz Woman in Coffee Shop Rebecca Hurlbert Amanda’s Deceased Classmate Lou Consolo Congressional Security Terrence Brown Congressional Security Ali Crawford Congressional Aide Harold Denson Congressional Aide Amy Kriner Congressional Aide Michael Nasca Theater Goer Abigale Pfingsten Theater Goer Merrilee Gilbert Theater Goer Barb Deevers Theater Goer Angelique Michelle Theater Goer Phil Nardozzi Theater Goer Kathy Ciesielski Theater Goer Mikayla Lecocq Theater Goer Dapper Levi Young Matthew's Dog Richard C. Fishel Amanda’s Dog in Photo Billy S. Fishel Amanda’s Dog in Photo Checkers Fishel Amanda’s Cat in Photo Larry D. Fishel Amanda’s Cat in Photo Max Morrow Coffee Shop Patron Giana Ferrelli Coffee Shop Patron Shawn Battlochi Coffee Shop Patron Angela Mass Comedy Show Patron Jessica Conley Comedy Show Patron Chris Pirollo Comedy Show Patron Christina Kemp Comedy Show Patron Stephanie Nix Comedy Show Patron Gary Topolosky Comedy Show Patron Megan Topolosky Comedy Show Patron Dylan Banner Comedy Show Patron Jake Paskorz Arcade Game Player Gregory Begg Funeral Home Employee Lauren Pfennigwerth Funeral Attendee Ryan Rayner Funeral Attendee Grayson McLennan Funeral Attendee Koree Shubert Funeral Attendee Jennifer Harris Funeral Attendee Max Wieland Funeral Attendee Daniel Buccigrossi Funeral Attendee Casey Loren Funeral Attendee John Augustin Funeral Attendee Katelyn Butler Funeral Attendee Fiona Butler Funeral Attendee Tobias Hurlbert Funeral Attendee Seth Hurlbert Funeral Attendee Diane Swearingen Coffee Shop Patron Kait Long Coffee Shop Patron Emmy Long Coffee Shop Patron Naomi Grodin Art Gallery Patron Roman D'Antonio Art Gallery Patron Montaja Simmons Art Gallery Patron Dom Spino Art Gallery Patron Tawni Nine Art Gallery Patron Phil Salvato Art Gallery Patron Emma Mycoff Coffee Shop Patron Katie Dunlap Coffee Shop Patron Joellen Smith Coffee Shop Patron Miranda Krause Coffee Shop Patron Michelle Kuhn Coffee Shop Patron Kassidi Kolano Coffee Shop Patron Miriam Elise Coffee Shop Patron Stephanie Miller Coffee Shop Patron Richard Constantine Coffee Shop Patron Angela Alfonso Coffee Shop Patron Cathy Ferrelli Coffee Shop Patron Danielle Dishong Coffee Shop Patron Benjamin Keller Coffee Shop Patron Elizabeth Evanick Coffee Shop Patron Brendan Senaway Coffee Shop Patron Julie Loesch Coffee Shop Patron Tracy Byers Coffee Shop Patron David Perminter Coffee Shop Patron Brian Horvath Bike Shop Cafe Patron